Is the Customer Always Right? 3 Cases That Debunk the Cliché

stock-image-25735061

Imagine compiling a list of marketing clichés. It wouldn’t be complete without the immortal „the customer is always right,” coined in 1909 by Harry Selfridge, the founder of Selfridge’s department store in London. And here we are, 100 years later, repeating the same mantra.

Bret Larson, CEO eVisit.com, calls this philosophy „one of the most dangerous business models.” (source) Steve Jobs, on the other hand, was famous for his skepticism towards consumers’ ability to understand their needs: „You can’t just ask customers what they want and then try to give that to them. By the time you get it built, they’ll want something new”. (source)

Both point out the same fact: that attempting to embrace and please all your customers doesn’t always pay. Below we describe 3 situations that should raise a flag.


Inbound Marketing doesn’t work in your business? Download free ebook and learn why


 

1. Customers insult your reps

What happens: Ironically, Apple delivers a stunning example of “consumers are always right” mentality. Once a customer came into the store, demanding her broken iPhone to be fixed immediately. Although the device was out of warranty, her screams and insults finally forced reps to give her a new iPhone on the spot.

Why customer is wrong: Nobody has right to offend your staff. It lowers team’s morale and attracts the audience you don’t want: demanding individuals who will eat up your time and energy without giving much in return. You won’t miss them.

Another problem is that such model favors aggressive and impolite people over civilized ones. Do you really want to do it?

How to react: Don’t let audience cross the line and don’t expect your employees to take the beating and turn the other cheek. Your top priority should be to serve the good, promising customers on the highest possible level.

 

2. Actual customer behavior differs from survey declarations

What happens: When Jobs criticizes the results of surveys and focus groups, he means that people are no good at assessing and predicting their own behavior. Simply put, we tend to overestimate our engagement, altruism or hard-working. As a result, surveys show participants’ self-images, not their readiness to buy a product or opinions on it.

Why customer is wrong: It’s humane to see ourselves as better than we actually are. It occurs unintentionally, with no evil intent. In the survey, when you pay with nothing more than a couple of minutes and a few mouse clicks, it’s easy to declare anything.

Not to mention that your group might not be representative if respondents were tempted with an incentive or possible reward.

How to react: When you search for product development inspirations, don’t limit yourself to surveys but use behavioral and transactional data and analytics, or resort to A/B testing.

Marketing Automation platform, which collects all customer data in one place so that you can see both: big, global trends regarding your whole base and individual user’s behavior.  

It doesn’t mean you should abandon surveys. Just know their pros and cons.

 

3. Customers aren’t experts

What happens: Often your customers won’t agree for your offer and keep on thinking up new options or stick to their own disputable concepts (of which you’re sure they’ll backfire).

Why customer is wrong: After years in your business you probably just know what works best. And some people simply are suspicious and want to manifest their opinions and stand.

How to react: Firstly, respect customers’ feelings and don’t belittle their concerns. Even if they are wrong, there’s no need to ignore them. Rather try to understand what disturbs them to prepare a better argumentation.

A good idea is also to educate your customer – produce content that helps understand your niche and make a purchase decision. Also, introduce Lead Nurturing campaigns.


Learn more about Lead Nurturing


 

 

It works both in B2B, B2C, and ecommerce.

The „customer is always right” cliché is founded on the wrong assumption that the more customers, the merrier, and that there are no bad consumers. But they exist. They’ll eat up your time and energy, spoil the atmosphere in the team and make you neglect customers about whom you should care.  

Being customer-centric doesn’t mean worshipping every single person that appears in your store. Manage your resources to address the most promising customers first, and don’t try to make everyone love you – it leads to neurosis and lowering the service quality.

Share your experience now: do bad customers happen to you? Do you remember the most unpleasant situation?

 

 

SALESmanago is a Customer Engagement Platform for impact-hungry eCommerce marketing teams who want to be lean yet powerful, trusted revenue growth partners for CEOs. Our AI-driven solutions have already been adopted by 2000+ mid-size businesses in 50 countries, as well as many well-known global brands such as Starbucks, Vodafone, Lacoste, KFC, New Balance and Victoria’s Secret.

SALESmanago delivers on its promise of maximizing revenue growth and improving eCommerce KPIs by leveraging three principles: (1) Customer Intimacy to create authentic customer relationships based on Zero and First Party Data; (2) Precision Execution to provide superior Omnichannel customer experience thanks to Hyperpersonalization; and (3) Growth Intelligence merging human and AI-based guidance enabling pragmatic and faster decision making for maximum impact.

More information: www.salesmanago.com

SALESmanago launches powerful personalisation tool to drive eCommerce revenue
SALESmanago launches powerful personalisation tool to drive eCommerce revenue

    Developed to answer marketers’ need for increased personalisation, this new AI-driven tool empowers eCommerce teams with scenarios which create tailored customer experiences News comes as Black Friday eCommerce results highlight that 19% more interaction was created by marketers using personalisation techniques    Krakow/Poland, January 15, 2025:  SALESmanago, Europe’s leading Customer Engagement Platform with […]

SALESmanago partners with PrestaShop to expand AI-driven customer engagement reach to European eCommerce businesses
SALESmanago partners with PrestaShop to expand AI-driven customer engagement reach to European eCommerce businesses

    Channel partnership follows SALESmanago’s recent acquisition of Leadoo, as the company furthers its European Customer Engagement Platform expansion   Krakow/Poland, December 18, 2024: SALESmanago, the SaaS powerhouse with over 3,000 customers, has announced a strategic channel partnership with PrestaShop, one of Europe’s most widely used eCommerce platforms which enables over 300,000 businesses to […]

Case Study: How Subdued Scaled with SALESmanago
Case Study: How Subdued Scaled with SALESmanago

  Subdued’s ROI reached a staggering 2065%, with 50% of sales driven by automation. With automated workflows and customer segmentation in place, Subdued could focus on future expansion, backed by actionable insights from customer data.​   About SubduedSubdued, a brand for independent teenagers, started in Italy in the ’90s and now operates 130 stores globally, […]

Black Friday 2024 Decoded: Key Insights to Boost Your eCommerce Strategy
Black Friday 2024 Decoded: Key Insights to Boost Your eCommerce Strategy

    What separates Winners from Wishers? Yes, it’s data. In the high-stakes arena of eCommerce, Black Friday is no longer just a shopping event—it’s a strategic battlefield where marketing precision determines victory. This year, eCommerce brands have continued to leverage advanced marketing techniques to engage their customers, drive higher conversions, and maximise sales. Here […]

SALESmanago and Leadoo join forces to build Europe’s largest Customer Engagement Platform and drive mid-market eCommerce growth
SALESmanago and Leadoo join forces to build Europe’s largest Customer Engagement Platform and drive mid-market eCommerce growth

    SALESmanago acquires SaaS marketing technology conversion platform Leadoo as part of mission to become Europe’s number one CEP Helsinki-headquartered Leadoo will strengthen SALESmanago’s presence in the UK, Nordics and Benelux, powering eCommerce customer growth with deep insights and personalisation   Krakow/Poland & Helsinki/Finland, November 26th, 2024: SALESmanago, the European SaaS powerhouse with over […]

CMO Role Getting Too Tight? Try Being A Growth Hacker Instead
CMO Role Getting Too Tight? Try Being A Growth Hacker Instead

    by Katrin Lewandowski, Senior Marketing Director at SALESmanago   The year is 2024, and the traditional Chief Marketing Officer (CMO) role is experiencing a transformation. Prominent companies, including brands like UPS and Etsy, have moved to eliminate or repurpose the CMO position—redistributing its responsibilities to roles such as Chief Commercial or Strategy Officers. […]

Skeletons in the eCommerce closet. Which one is your worst nightmare?
Skeletons in the eCommerce closet. Which one is your worst nightmare?

    As Halloween draws near, the urgency to unveil and exorcise the lurking skeletons from eCommerce closets becomes increasingly palpable. Just as the haunted season prompts us to confront our fears, the digital landscape compels businesses to confront the formidable challenges that often remain concealed.   In 2024, the stakes for eCommerce companies have […]

eCommerce Booms and Stagnates
eCommerce Booms and Stagnates

    By Brian Plackis Cheng, CEO at SALESmanago   Commerce is fickle; it stagnates and booms. Customer journeys are non-linear. And these are the things we know for sure. Without actionable customer data and personalised journeys, eCommerce companies are losing customers and prospects, eroding their brand, and sacrificing their competitive edge.    Embracing zero-party […]