How to ruin perfect product? 5 lessons from failure of cheapest car ever

New Tata Car "Nano" at Autoexpo in Delhi, IndiaImagine yourself a scooter. And 30-year man on it. And a woman behind him. And two kids behind her (yes, still on the same scooter). Cuddled tight against each other, they set off and drive through crowded, noisy street.

When Ratan Tata saw such situation, he decided to do something about it. People, no matter what their social position is, deserve some dignity! So he thought up a solution: the cheapest automobile ever, car for the people.

History of his failure provides excellent insight into consumer psychology, comments Shamim Akhtar from Mizoram University.

Marketing Fairy Tale about perfect car

It was supposed to be an ideal product, consumers’ dream fulfilled; cheap, cute, safe and good-quality car. Tata Motors is a market leader: biggest vehicle producer in India, fourth in the world, with over 60 years of experience in automotive.

It was a classic example of restrictions (future price mainly) leading to innovations. Group of experienced engineers designed optimal car.

So why didn’t sales reflect it?

Logic is sometimes false, or why wouldn’t you want a car?

Tata assumed that every bike or scooter owner dreams about possessing a car, but just can’t afford it. The only barrier is cost of a car, so if we create one that costs as much as 3 scooters, the poor will buy it immediately. Seems legit.

So listen to what real target customers of cheapest car say and why don’t they want it:

  • They don’t have a place to park it or garage
  • They like their actual means of transportation (smaller, more mobile than a car)
  • They are anxious about driving, don’t feel secure behind the wheel
  • Relatively high costs of maintenance,

Such problems couldn’t even cross moto giant’s head.

Too expensive for the poor, too cheap for the wealthier

To producers’ surprise, Nano car was mostly purchased by middle class. 80% of buyers have already had one car before. But even in that group Nano was far from success. For them the price was disturbingly low, especially that in India relationship between price and quality is perceived very traditionally as proportional. Nano epitomized then low social status.

Saving on marketing

Is a car safer or more convenient than a bike? Do high price always mean high quality? That could be open to discussion. Introducing Nano would be an excellent opportunity, if anyone was willing to start debating. From our perspective we could say that Lead Nurturing was missing: campaign addressed to various users, providing knowledge and responding to skepticism could show product as something what it actually is: a good car.

Marketing means communication with customers, informing about possibilities of our product, resolving doubts, answering questions.

Lessons about customer psychology from Tata Motors

  • Don’t trust your intuitions – do research
  • Don’t assume that your customer is just like you, that you share ideas, mindset, and values. Instead, try to listen: interpret his signals, talk to him, run tests. Use all feedback possible: social media, customer service, Marketing Automation analytics
  • Customer education is a must: saving on marketing, because your product is great and doesn’t need it, will backfire
  • Product needs specific target. It’s not like: “Somebody will love it, if not these, then those”.
  • Lowest possible price isn’t always the best idea.

 

(Read more: Shamim Akhtar, Behind the Nano Mistakes: A Case Study on Consumer Psychology, Srusti Management Review, Vol. VI, Issue I, January 2013)

SALESmanago is a Customer Engagement Platform for impact-hungry eCommerce marketing teams who want to be lean yet powerful, trusted revenue growth partners for CEOs. Our AI-driven solutions have already been adopted by 2000+ mid-size businesses in 50 countries, as well as many well-known global brands such as Starbucks, Vodafone, Lacoste, KFC, New Balance and Victoria’s Secret.

SALESmanago delivers on its promise of maximizing revenue growth and improving eCommerce KPIs by leveraging three principles: (1) Customer Intimacy to create authentic customer relationships based on Zero and First Party Data; (2) Precision Execution to provide superior Omnichannel customer experience thanks to Hyperpersonalization; and (3) Growth Intelligence merging human and AI-based guidance enabling pragmatic and faster decision making for maximum impact.

More information: www.salesmanago.com

Skeletons in the eCommerce closet. Which one is your worst nightmare?
Skeletons in the eCommerce closet. Which one is your worst nightmare?

    As Halloween draws near, the urgency to unveil and exorcise the lurking skeletons from eCommerce closets becomes increasingly palpable. Just as the haunted season prompts us to confront our fears, the digital landscape compels businesses to confront the formidable challenges that often remain concealed.   In 2024, the stakes for eCommerce companies have […]

eCommerce Booms and Stagnates
eCommerce Booms and Stagnates

    By Brian Plackis Cheng, CEO at SALESmanago   Commerce is fickle; it stagnates and booms. Customer journeys are non-linear. And these are the things we know for sure. Without actionable customer data and personalised journeys, eCommerce companies are losing customers and prospects, eroding their brand, and sacrificing their competitive edge.    Embracing zero-party […]

Plateau of Productivity – Business vs AI face off 2024
Plateau of Productivity – Business vs AI face off 2024

    YouTuber Tomasz Rożek’s channel, “Science. I like It,” recently featured a fascinating discussion on “Next Steps of AI Expansion” with Aleksandra Katarzyna Przegalińska-Skierkowska. While the lack of English subtitles remains a mystery, the conversation itself is a must-watch.   Plateau of productivity   Tomasz Rożek graduated in physics and journalism from the University […]

Are Your Marketing Strategies Future-Proof? A Mid-Year Check-In for CMOs
Are Your Marketing Strategies Future-Proof? A Mid-Year Check-In for CMOs

    As we have crossed the midpoint of 2024, it’s an opportune moment for Chief Marketing Officers (CMOs) to evaluate progress and ensure their strategies align with… the “dynamic landscape” would be an understatement, really. With Gartner identifying AI integration, evolving marketing roles, and cross-functional growth as top priorities for 2024, CMOs need to […]

How Focus Garden Cultivated Unprecedented Growth with SALESmanago
How Focus Garden Cultivated Unprecedented Growth with SALESmanago

    Focus Garden, the premier destination for high-quality garden furniture and supplies, cultivates success as meticulously as their customers cultivate their gardens. We’re proud to support the company in their digital journey, focused strategically overcoming challenges and setting new standards in customer engagement.   In less than a year, our collaborative efforts with Focus […]